by Uncle Josh
Blog Link
I've been reading Tony Pierce's blog for about two months now, since Shane Nickerson recommended him to his readers.
But I have to say that I haven't seen much in the way of substance. Sure, the guy is a good writer but I've known plenty of good writers that have dick to say.
I went to writing school with writers that put Bus Blog writing to shame and a lot of those writers are doing dick with their talent; either because they saw no light at the end of the penis shaft called publishing or because they lost all their drive in the crash to get the BFA or because they had no vision in the first place, just raw talent and a flaming desire to piss off their parents with a next to worthless degree in corporate eyes.
But, the worst thing you can do as a writer is grab the mike, the pen, or the keyboard and waste your nation's time.
I hate to say it, but a lot of Bus Blog and Wil Wheaton and even Nickerblog's stuff is mental masturbation that comes from egos too large that haven't been checked and curbed by talented and skilled writers in a peer group.
These guys are talented but they jerk off a lot on the screen too; and that's okay, just don't expect me to stand around and watch it drizzle down. I wouldn't do this any more than I would have asked to read my fellow BGBFA compadres private writing journals. Who gives a shit? Get to the meat already. No one cares about what movie you watched last weekend and how much you enjoyed it. Does the movie have something to do with what's going on in our lives? Then stick it in the clouds and come back to earth, already.
We need to know what you think about important shit, not the mechanics and operations of the poker match you played last weekend.
I respect all authors in the blogging community and fully support the right to free exchange of information and emotion; but the First Amendment guarantees us a right to speak freely, not an audience to listen to what we have to say.
And what I'm saying is that the Blogosphere is an information market where the currency is time and attention, which is the most valuable commodity in human existence. Like any market, there are unspoken standards, invisible hands with fingers snapping. If your product (your blog) isn't dancing in tune with the snaps, you're gonna find yourself without a chair when the music stops and your audience has moved on to the next song.
So, fellow bloggers, don't be surprised when you get out of place if someone like me steps in to slam you back into the locker that all writing geeks crawl out of when the jocks and lipstick cock whores aren't looking and can't shove us back in.
[Update: I just liked the sound of "lipstick cock whore" but this would never make it past my editing team which is why it's on a blog and not one of my articles.]
Sho' Nuff!
UPDATE #1:
Shane Nickerson posted a blog entry in response to this post here.
UPDATED #2:
Look, this whole thing came about because I had an adverse reaction to Tony's column where he basically threw down the gauntlet and called himself king shit and said everyone needs to bow down to his blog if they were ever going to be considered anything in the blogosphere. Well, I had only been reading his stuff for a couple months so I didn't see the sack that went with the hype.
Then I began thinking about what Wil and Shane had been posting about for the last few weeks as well and I thought, "How are they maintaining these many thousands of people daily who keep coming back for this fluff?" So, I posted this blog to confront my audience with the issue. It got picked up and became the topic of much bigger conversations and much larger audiences than I am used to entertaining here in my home. But this is a good thing because the question is out on the table.
What the fug are you people doing with your time that you consider it well spent to tune in to spaced out entries and rambling blog posts that go on like the Dead singing Turn on Your Lovelight at an Acid Test?
See, what frustrates me so much is that there is only so much attention to go around and if that attention is getting used up with the mundanities and trivialities of the lives of actors and voyeurs who put their diaries out on the web, then that means even less attention will be paid to the important things--you know, civil defense, the war on terror, economic, healthcare, and education reform--that sort of thing. I'm talking about the things that have dramatic impacts on every person's life on this planet.
I believe it is each citizen's duty to arm themselves with information that does not come from a a centralized or corporate source and I see blogs as a way to circumvent that very dangerous situation.
However, if you're just here to have fun or engage in mindless mental voyeurisms then step out of the way before I step over ya' (to quote Andrew Dice Clay).
Consider it a Cluetrain Manifesto to bloggers to keep it real or take it the fuck home because the game just got serious.
UPDATE #3: Malatron from A Blog Soup brings some levity to the whole situation--which I am completely done with--Jesus, my marriage isn't even this hard! And I'm giving props to Tony for schoolin' me on turning blog posts into photo journals that add weight to content--good lookin' out, holmes]
UPDATE #5: See, this is serious and exactly what I'm talking about as far as substance in blog posts.
UPDATE #6: I've Been a Dick About all This and Here is My Apology to Tony, Shane and Wil
Related Posts (on one page):
- Ed Adkins Really Knows How to Piss People Off Online
- Reflections on Position a Month After the Blogging Wars
- When a Man is Wrong and the Benefits and Drawbacks of Pissing Off Tony Pierce
- "Go Ahead and Draw--I'll Make Ya' Famous!" Thoughts on Positioning in the Aftermath of the Ideology of Blogging Wars
- Bus Blog? I'm Not Impressed...
Other Posts in the Category:
This blog was originally posted on July 18, 2005


The BWP Comment Policy
Guest are encouraged to leave comments here; you do not have to register an account. All that I ask is that you be respectful of the other readers of this site and its host. Stick to the ideas being expressed and you should be okay. Get personal and you might not like the results. Thanks for reading.and ive been focused more on starting up my podcast blog, which will start bumping fully very soon.
with that said, this summer ive been most happy with my political coverage like this rove roundup, scotty mcclellan's bad day, and this critique of the instapundit's lack of coverage about the summer's hottest scandal.
meanwhile i have been dipping back into the archives once in a while to remind the kids that i can write. and if its not your cup of tea, then whatever. different strokes.
but before you bail out, perhaps you should maybe try to figure out why it is that im one of the most-linked and most-influencial bloggers around.
is it my photo essays, the fact that ive been doing this for quite quite a while, or because sometimes good writing isnt about fullblown creativity or angry rants.
sometimes good writing is about creating a personae, cultivating a community, and keeping things fresh.
i am not a famous child star, im not a hollywood actor, im not a hot chick, and yet i get hella hits. theres a reason. and theres a reason why (as i blogged today) heavy weight political far right wing bloggers like instapundit and little green footballs link me and far left rockstar/activists like matt good link me.
its not because i kiss their ass, cuz i dont. its not because i have any "power" - those blogs get more hits than i. and its not because my design or spelling or, as you say, content, is so revolutionary.
my belief is they appreciate the full package.
and a word of advice. if youre going to say a guy isnt a great writer, but you know some who are far superior, show those people's majesty. link to it. provide examples.
if im going to poo-poo a poet and say that i can bust rhymes better than them, id show them ilka or the stamp. but i wouldnt dare do that because i wrote those things in college...
anyway. thanks for giving me a chance this summer. sorry i wasnt very inspired or inspiring. but if you dont have any examples of better blogs or better writing, you may come off as jealous and/or playa-hatin. and i dont think thats your intention.
you be the judge.
and if you see the light, id appreciate a link next to those gentlemen shane and wil.
danke.
But you're right as far as providing the goods. The truth is that out of all the writers I went to school with, only a few are online and the two with blogs (David Tran and Jon Williams) haven't quite embraced the power of their blog to build up their online brand like you were talking about.
By far, the most commercially successful of my BFA class of 2000 is Marc Sumerak who, after working for three years as an Assistant Editor at Marvel, is now writing kick ass comic books and getting paid some serious duckets.
Me, I believe in another way instead of traditional publishing. I started my own company this year and I'm taking my five years of ass-kissing and soul searching in corporate American and am starting to talk about business in general, healthcare in particular and I'm fully into internet publishing.
I have a book on how artists and authors can take advantage of the internet to begin building up their brand with blogs, podcasts and a static html site to house their stories, poems, music, etc. My book is going to be available online only and through my own site (keep it small and keep it all).
The book's title is Flipping the Temple: Win the Information War Using the Internet to Achieve Fantasic Sucess as and Author or Artist and I'm aiming at completely demolishing the bullshit corporate structure of the sale of information and entertainment in this country.
As far as the photo journals go, I owe you an apology because the ones you've produced that I've read have been kick ass! You are right to stand on their merit and I give you props.
I assure you, my man; I am no hater. It is because I respect your talent and your potential that I made the comments the way I did (I played to your Blogger's Vanity in order to make a statement that you would take some time to listen to and for that, I offer my thanks for your time).
I believe that your timely response to my statements has shown you to be a writer and a human being of integrity and you are therefore worthy of addition to my blogroll. You will be added within the day, Tony and I will continue to subscribe to your RSS feeds.
Keep 'em comin' brother but don't forget that respect goes both ways online...
Now, if you'll excuse me (and the blatant American Psycho reference), I have to go return some video tapes...
I'm not sure because it got hazy in the hipocracy.
Anyway, the cool thing -I think- about these guys is watching them have these sudden small realizations that the big things in life *are* actually the family and the community and what-not. That even when we're mired in societal shit, it's such a fucking Great Thing to be able to flip a burger on a summer eve or watch your kid dance in a mirror and have a moment of 'hey...it's alright. That's alright.'
And its a universal feeling, y'know? Whether you get it from your family or just watching family guy...its moments of transcendence. And it'll be those that you remember and pine for the most.
Not the headlines.
So we need those every now and again. For perspectives' sake.
oh, and your argument is self-defeating for many reasons but the most evident being in the way you present it.
and no, I'm not a blogger. And the world is probably better for not having to endure the cynicism (but then, they could always choose not to endure it... which is always the easy answer to criticism such as yours. But I wanted to go a bit further. If only a bit.)
But yes, anonymous, you're right that this whole argument carries a certain measure of hypocrisy because the moment I post something about serene family life, I've stepped outside the bounds of what I established as "proper missionary blog positioning for insertion of the erect blog post into the waiting blogosphere."
So, let me pause for a moment and say that I do post those types of entries, but I try to relegate them to my family blog which deals more with parenting issues and responses to news events that affect family life.
This way, I can keep my readers separated and they can cross over whenever they see fit but at the same time stay in my funnel in the place they are most comfortable.
But cynicism, pessimism and defeatism is something that my readers will never find on any my blogs or in any of my published writings.
I'm all about helping others achieve what their passions are driving them towards (provided these passions do not infringe upon the lives or property of others) while at the same time making choices based on a proper paradigm and core values in my own life.
I promised myself when I was nineteen that I would not die with my song still inside me and I won't.
Thanks for your candor, anonymous; that type of honesty is always welcome here on my blog.
I read Tony and Shane and Wil (and have linked them to the piddling few readers that I have as well), because they're all interesting.
I'll admit that half of the poker play-by-play goes over my head and sometimes I get too hung up on punctuation and capitalization to absorb Tony's stuff, but the beauty of the blog as a form of expression is that it doesn't have to be anything, and no one owes it to anyone to be anything other that what they are.
I don't get your particular obsession with phallic imagery, for instance, but it's an obvious, instant signature. Although I honestly find it a little cloying and juvenile.
For me, I just do what makes me laugh, or makes me think. And it can be as simple as just putting up little road markers that make it easy to go back and remember what was going on in my life. Regardless of what anyone else thinks.
So, if I'm Tony or I'm Wil or Shane, and I look at what I've written, and I'm happy, or say, "fuck it, I was too occupied with my real life to worry too much about this shit," or I swear that I'm going to do better, then that's what it is. And fuck everyone else who reads. If you're not doing it for yourself, you're not doing it for the right reasons.
how are you doing your part to improve the world? why are you taking blogging so seriously (that you have to call someone out)? what do you care what someone writes on their blog? are you not familiar with the concept of blogging? the great part of blogging is its extreme levels of self-indulgence, exhibitionism, and voyeurism.
no one is making you read anything on the internet, quit acting like a stranger owes you a favor.
So, fellow bloggers, don't be surprised when you get out of place if someone like me steps in to slam you back into the locker that all writing geeks crawl out of when the jocks and lipstick cock whores aren't looking and can't shove us back in.
that is just stupid. seriously. who the fuck died and made you Blog Judge? are you trying to instill fear? what are you trying to accomplish? make people walk the way you want them to walk?
you have control issues, whoever you are. maybe you'll wake up someday and realize how POINTLESS this all is.
let people be who they are.
Consider:
"maybe afraid of it/let's discredit it/let's pick away at it/I want to watch it come down/now doesn't that make you feel better?/the pigs have won tonight/now they can all sleep soundly/and everything is all right"
It seems that that the lurkers and part-time bloggers out there that make up the long tail are interested only in being entertained while the world crumbles around them.
Well, my name ain't Nero and I don't have a fiddle. Now, shut up and take your medicine.
The fire is burning, man pull your own weight.
You had me at genuine until you pumped your book, and this is not a slam against your tactics it is a props because you are right in the potential that blogs lead and the uncanny open dorrway that an online spectrum of non-sense information transfer allows for the future of the international market place.
I myself am developing an online clotihng market, and charitable events sector out of Canada, and the growth in blog traffic to both myself and to those who support my endeavours (www.paigesix.blogspot.com) only leaves me wet at the chops anticipating the capital to move forward with my endeavours.
You indeed dove head first into the shibuya market of online exposure, and with that I applaud your efforts.
I am going to link your site out of gusto appreciation alone, and best of luck in your market missions.
wishes for buckets of duckets for all of us in the future.
I always like when people say there are better people that can do something only those people chose not to. I call bullshit. Tony's not the perfect blogger but who gives a shit really? I have other things I HAVE to give a shit about. Blogging is an interesting form of grafitti to me and I don't use any blog to plot my thought pattern.
Tony is a friend I've never met. I enjoy him most days and some days I don't but he never comes off as elitest.
Everybody's a critic. Write to please yourself. If people enjoy it consider it a bonus.
Thanks for the comments and support, my man.
The world is not waiting for the blogging masses to sweep it out of chaos and into some new utopia. Blogging is just another form of entertainment and expression. If you think George W. is going to wake up one day, log onto a blog full of tired dick jokes and suddenly realize the answer to balancing the budget, cleanly withdrawing from Iraq, firing Karl Rove and lowering oil prices, you've got to find something else to do with your time.
I have yet to see a single thing on YOUR blog that elevates you into any upper echelon from which you can pronounce judgement on everyone else. No particular insight. Just some links and a little opinion.
Never mind Tony, Shane, Wil and all my other daily reads. You're my new blogging hero. Someday I aspire to your grand level of pretension.
And as far as the question, "Well, who are yew to judge. Hoo er yew?"
I'll quote Bill Hicks, "I'm me. It's true. Shut the feck up."
And you didn't read deep enough, dog. There's a nugget of pure gold hidden up here on the upper echelon. Climb up out of the donkeyswamp and holla' at me sometime.
"I ain't no white trash piece of shit; I'm better 'n you all. I can outread you. I can out thank you. And I can out philosaphaize you. And Imma outlass you. You think a couple whacks to my good ole' boy gut's goin' get me down? It'll take a helluva lot more'n that to prove yer better'n me, Counselor."
heeheheehehehe...
Anyway, I'm closing the book on this one--no more responses from me on this. Feel free to post what you want anyone, I might drop in from time to time to check it all out.
The moral of the story is, if you don’t like what someone has to say, fuck’em. If you feel the need to tell them they’re wrong or why they’re an idiot, feel free but, realize two things: 1) it probably makes you more egotistical, prickish and idiotic than the original person, and; 2) there’s a distinct possibility it’s a total waste of time and energy. As for me, I’m just a public employee who has a lot of free time on his hands and likes to objectively observe the circus that is humanity. That being said, I’ll go back to wasting your tax dollars.
Lighten up and fuck you kindly,
El Bastardo Fantastico!
And josh, you did redeem yourself with your apology and you humanized yourself with the story about yelling at your child. That alone made me want to hear more of what you had to say